Yuusha Party wo Tsuihou Sareta Ore da ga, Ore kara Sudatte Kureta you de Ureshii. Nanode Daiseijo, Omae ni Otte Korarete wa Komaru no da ga? - MangaUpdates

banner

Baka-Updates

Manga

User Comments [ Order by usefulness ]

Bad even by Isekai standards

by tigerstar186
1 month ago

Rating: 1.0 / 10.0

You know something sucks when it's exceptionally bad in a genre that's already notorious for being bad.

I kept sticking with it... Maybe it will get better, maybe something interesting will happen.

Nope.

It is the most generic shit you've ever seen without a single likable character or standout moment. Worse still, the characters aren't bland, they're actively unlikeable. The MC refuses to communicate with anyone and then questions why he is where he is in life. He's an enabler of shitty behaviour for years because he's too lazy to say one sentence.

Worse still, the narrative tries to paint him as a saint for it. What a good guy he is. How cool he is. Look at all those girls who instantly love him the second they see something mildly positive. So impressive.

Ugh.

Was this comment useful? Yes

No

Some Is Good, But Held Back By Tropes

by LazyReviewer
1 year ago

Rating: 5.0 / 10.0

Most of the characters are written well enough to not be bad, except for one of the most important characters: the "hero" who kicked the main character out of the party.

The hero's other party members... it's a mixed bag. The tank is neutral, since he's not really given enough panel space to give him a recognizable personality.

The monk/punch monkey girl is as obnoxious as the "hero".

The mage girl... honestly, there were and are some really interesting things being done with her, but the execution in writing her is a bit lacking.

The MC and holy maiden's replacements are actually okay in terms of writing.

The world building is okay, if a bit lacking.

The real issue is how the main character, despite being intelligent (emotionally, strategicly and intellectually), can't see the "hero" for being the horrible person he really is, and that constantly has to be brought up, which is a weird thing to do.

This story tries so hard to make the MC feel like a dad to the hero party, but in trying to do so, creates a dissonance that strains or breaks suspension of disbelief.

I can't decide if it's worth recommending, because the good elements are undermined by the bad ones.

Was this comment useful? Yes

No

author is a chunni

by trunkallergy
2 years ago

Rating: 4.0 / 10.0

MC is the type of guy to tell the main arc villain that there were too many enemies, so he killed them all in one hit. Just stop

Was this comment useful? Yes

No

Waste of time

by BeerDrinker
2 years ago

Rating: 1.0 / 10.0

Pro tip: every single story with the premise "adventurer is kicked out of hero/s rank party" is absolute shit. All of them. Read something else.

Why this is shit: no one explains or listens to anyone. MC is an overpowered Gary Stu buffer that never told his party he was buffing all of their stats by 1000 times constantly, The Saintess knows this but also didn't say anything.
The other members are cartoonish asshole idiots with 1 braincell, they don't realize all their power comes from MC, so without him they are completely trashed at the first dungeon, when they are gone the Saintess shows she is OP too and leaves them to return to MC beacause she idolizes him, why didn't she leave with him before but stayed with the assholes? Literally no reason other than shit writing.

The chapter after he is kicked out MC frees an overpowered dragon loli that immediately falls in love with him; he forgives every insult, never gets angry at anyone and has a spell to resolve every single dangerous situtation.
The drawings aren't close to good enough to carry this.

It's worse than shit, it's an insult to the reader's intelligence and time.
Vote: waste of paper, ink and storage space.
Read something else.

... Last updated 2 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

No

Boring

by superman89
2 years ago

Rating: 2.0 / 10.0

MC is the I don't care about anything type with unlimited powers. If it's done right it's not too bad but this is just atrocious.

No matter what the MC faces he can defeat it. Why was he kicked out of the hero party then? Well he chose not to show his real powers, duh!

Just a garbage plot. I'm not sure why the MC just doesn't pull out the 'I can defeat the entire world skill'? Way too many asspulls with the MC's power and a stale overused plot device. Much better version out anyways.

... Last updated 2 years ago

Was this comment useful? Yes

No