First of all, as someone who often reads shounen manga, I am prepared to find some crappy jokes and gag shounen-like actions in this manga. I also expect to see how the Sket Dance club (i.e., the three of them) would just be all comical and never be serious, HOWEVER, that impression quickly changes after a few more chapters onwards.
Of course, I wouldn't deny that some chapters are boring and the comedy part is forced (I always feel like skipping those chapters when that weird teacher--what's the name again?--appears. And yeah, he appears quite..... numerous). There's also part that I feel like skipping when it's just all about gags, or when the trio do weird experiments using Chuu-san's medicines. At least, I pretty much like the tsukkimi part, lol.
As we move on, the story starts to grow more serious--if not "normal"--, and it tells more about the interaction of the characters.
To be honest, I always want to make a manga in which all students have their own specialty, divided from first year to third year, and altogether, using their own individuality and special talents, they make school a very special places with lots of events going on every day. And Sket Dance just answers them all!
Bossun too, has a time when he's lame and weak, but he has a lot of special talents which makes him has his own spotlight moment.
It also strikes me that to make a manga interesting, it's more important to make the characters to appear "alive", rather than going on with the all-perfect-bishounen/shoujo. I think this is what makes a school life genre + shounen like Sket Dance special.
On the mangaka's note on last chapter, he mentioned about the low rate of female readers, but I can surely tell him that you have one-me- here!
Sket Dance doesn't only tell a story of high school life that everyone (may) dreams about. It also answers some questions about our life as high school students. "Do you regret your high school life?" "What would you say as you're graduating?" "What's your life career?" "What is justice?"
The chuunibyou that resides within everyone, lies in Sket Dance.
As a matter of whether it is a good manga or not, I think it depends on each people. You may not like a simple school life manga and expect the fantasy element, then you'd say this manga is boring. You might have pure disliking to this manga, and then you might start badmouthing it. For someone like me, who enjoys school life genre like this, I might overrated it. It's all depends on how much this story has touched or gave you.
Last but not least, I am very satisfied with the art! The characters look all cool in their own way! Another point that I like from this manga is also how their feelings are portrayed. I feel like the emotions when someone is doing the narrations totally nail my heart :')
Thanks for giving me a manga worth to read.