It's a good read. It's refreshing and fairly funny, although the cooking tends to be pretty boring and repetitive. Sure, it's interesting how they make use of all weird stuff they find, but I will never find cooking to be exciting or awesome to read about. Don't get me wrong, I personally like cooking good food at home, but reading about it in a manga? Nah. I would prefer it if they cut down a bit on the cooking parts, there's too much focus on food, I'm not saying it should be removed, I just think it'd be better if there was a little bit less and perhaps not every chapter. Sure, it's called "dungeon MESHI", but that doesn't mean there has to be so much of it since it tends to get repetitive quickly, especially if you're experienced in cooking and not a blank page.
I feel like people give out a 10/10 score way too easily. Currently, when I write this, 46%(114) people gave it a 10. That's ridiculous. Yeah, it's fine, it's pretty good, but even if I loved the cooking, I still wouldn't give it a 10. You know what 10 is? It's a perfect score, flawless. There's nothing to improve on. It's the ultimate work you can think of and you're unable to imagine anything that could be done better and your enjoyment parameters are through the roof. But do people feel that way? Nah, most people just think "Oh, this was awesome, I loved it" and drops a 10/10 because they really enjoyed it without anything notable they felt they needed to complain about... Sigh... I mean, a 9/10 is already ridiculous enough for a score, giving it that score means there's almost nothing you think could be done better and you loved it, enjoying it immensely and not having any moments where you thought it was a bit dull, repetitive or so-so. I feel like most of the people giving a 10 should probably give an 8/10 instead, the score always gets so screwed up when people rate something without caring about what is actually required to get such high ratings. It's amazing how this manga has almost no votes under 7 though, that just means it's great, and I agree. It's easily worth around 7, which is "Great", some complaints but nothing too major.