When I saw the cover, title, tags: "WOAH!!! LOOKS LIKE THIS IS IN MY BALLPARK! THE CHARACTERS APPEAR ON THE COVER ARE SO COOL LOOKING! AND THE PROTAG'S DESIGN LOOKS TO BE MY THING! "
However...
After getting through the 10-chapter mark, I couldn't be any further off my initial expectations (set by the glazing reviews most people here gave):
Here's my evaluation (My rating are based on how fun and intriguing I find reading it is):
VIBES: 7/10
ART: 10/10
FUN: 3/10
Recommended?
- If you are in to look for an amazing, critically acclaimed plot. You won't find it here.
- If you get intrigued in mysterious and well-researched world buildings, you might enjoy it 7-10.
- If you are an ART FIRST, STORY SECOND, I think that it'll be to your liking (essentially, the opposite of those who enjoy mangas like One Punch Man (not the one illustrated by Murata but the scribble-ish 'nemu' storyboard version by ONE)).
Personally, I'm the type of reading that looks for fun first. And it wasn't engaging enough for me. I thought I could find an interesting story, but was met with a pseudo DnD world building book. Allow me to elaborate:
Author has the same problem as J.R. R. Tolkien and Jules Vernes who focus 90% on the world building: Hence, there's barely any tension or stakes or threads of a high-stake plot brewing. OK, I get it, guys, you have this cool world in your head that you want to introduce us to! Essentially, you guys are making a very sophisticated sandbox template for everyone to build their own headcannon, which is very cool for board games and stuffs. But for a manga who mostly relies on the narrative to thrive, is that really the best medium?
When I face 'manga where nothing seems to happen in the beginning'. I always give it the benefit of doubt. I try to find what the author intend to be the 'highlight' of the series. For some manga, it seems to be a cozy Slice of Life experience. For some mangas, there's a hidden, thrilling conspiracy brewing beyond all the iceberg. For some manga, the characters' drama seems to be the bread and butter. WITH THIS MANGA, my problem with it is that doesn't go for any of the above mentioned archetype, but instead, rely on its WORLD BUILDING solely to carry it. If you do things this way as an author, then you don't seem to be someone with a story to tell, but a world to share. Then I ask this of you, wouldn't this have been better as ANYTHING BUT A MANGA? (e.g. Video game backdrop, board game setting, DnD session)
Now enough of the ranting, let's go and check how it does things:
Story-wise, it opens up like the typical slow burn series... but lacks some critical elements that make it enjoyable to read. I think it's the way that it does it: Boring info dump, uninteresting interactions that doesn't provide much value.
The problem is that the plot(?) or the things it tries to build towards is done in such a way where it can't grab my interest (believe me, I manage to crawl through Houseki no Kuni and Beastars with a similar slow lead but even so they managed to hold my interest---with subtle mystery, foreshadowing, intrigue, hints, and some light comedy---while this one lacks any redeeming elements that can retain my attention). Like c'mon, show me something interesting, crazy, cool, anything!! Well, for this manga author's language, it seems to be: "OH HERE"S SOME PRETTY ART AND MYSTICAL CREATURES, HOPE THAT'LL SATISFY YOUR FOMO."
It's not a bad "read" if you just enjoy some pretty nice eye candy, the author should go do set designs, costume designs to maximize the value of their skillset. Or world building like G R R Martin did for Elden Ring. That seems to be their strong suit after all.
I also don't mind reading through guidebooks or lore books if I find the "main narrative" interesting. I do that all the times with franchises with multiple lore spanning across multiple entries like Nier, Xenogears, etc. The reason why it won't work here with this series is that the main narrative DOES NOT EXIST WELL AS A STANDALONE.
As such, this whole thing might be better as an artbook only release if the author doesn't have energy to retool this series into something else. I swear, if this is novel-form or has stickman-level drawing care... it would receive this level of reverence. It speaks how much the art carries this series (lots of flair, and induces a really nice ambience).
So if you are looking for a "story" that can hold strong on their own, you won't be able to find it here. (Kuroshitsuji which has a similar aesthetics is more enjoyable 'plot-wise' even though I gave it shit for its weird direction; just because it feels like things are progressing...)