Plucky protagonist Nina, too innocent for her own good, falls in love with her childhood friend and hall-of-famer fuckup Mr. Mixed Signals Kyousuke, who seemingly rejects her feelings because she won't put out. Instead, driven by his savior complex, Kyousuke decides to start going out with another his club's manager Asou, and this is where I have to agree with a previous review that Asou was never the problem. Asou uses Kyousuke as a relief valve for the stress that her scumbag ex-boyfriend puts her through, but her situation and the situation of everyone else around them only gets so bad because of Kyousuke's repeated bad decision making. Kyousuke never even bothers to scare that scumbag ex away from Asou. He can't even do a proper job of having a savior complex!
You see, Kyousuke didn't reject Nina because she wouldn't give in to his attempts to kiss her. Instead, he rejected her because he genuinely puts no faith in her feelings and seemingly doesn't have any respect for her as an autonomous human being capable of making her own decisions and acting on her own emotions. What a relief! Is that better or worse? I don't know, you tell me. Kyousuke, go figure, decides that his hardline rejection of Nina's heartfelt feelings was a big oopsy when he realizes that she could just go find a better man, and while he doesn't do it on purpose, he does end up ruining her budding relationship with the love-quadrangle-bait Miyake, the boy too one-note to ever really serve as a serious rival (or can he...?), cockblocking Nina out of her uber-lifechanging Christmas date plans to finally give up the goods! If she does that then he could never kick Asou to the curb and hook up with his one true virginal love! Yeah it's a little gross, and the way the series handles sex is a bit eyeroll inducing.
A lot of plot contrivances ensue, you know the deal. If you've read a lot of middling shoujo romances you already know to expect the fated encounters, the misunderstandings, the "running into each other at the wrong time"s, the heartbreaker witnessed kisses, yadda yadda you've seen it all before. Does Nina eventually break through to her childhood love, or will she find a new blossoming romance somewhere else? There's really only two ways these tend to go. Oh, so it's bargain bin slop, been there done that, so why am I even writing this review? Well, I've got to give the series its flowers for maintaining its high tension and avoiding the filler arc pratfalls that make these stories feel like a huge waste of time. 10 volumes isn't that short, but it does feel like it goes by quicker than it could have otherwise. And at the end of the day, Nina is a charming character and you really want to see her shed the pain these characters are constantly putting her through. It's a pretty riveting read, and at the end of the day I'll take one of these over some boring action series or textdump isekai crap to put me to sleep.
And hey, I was happy to see Kyousuke not get his happy ending after all the shit he pulled. Turns out Miyake pulled off the hat trick, and he and Nina get to live happily ever after. While Asou continues getting harassed by her scumbag ex gripping the short end of the stick until the very last chapter. Wait no, Kyousuke gets a consolation prize too in the last volume in the form of another cute kouhai offering him an easy off-ramp. Fuck off!
So there you go, another childhood-friend "will-they-or-won't-they" "wait-why-don't-you" "you-easily-could!" "hurry-up-and-will-they-already!" "why-didn't-you-when-you-could?" romp. There's a million of 'em, and maybe a handful of good ones. Is this one of the good ones? Eh. At least it's got something resembling overarching themes. Solid 5.